This week’s Sunday morning International Game pits the Pittsburgh Steelers against the New Orleans Saints at Stade de France Stadium which is located near Paris. These are two teams that opened their National Football League schedules with high hopes yet more questions than answers.
The Steelers are under the direction of a new head coach, this is an organization that with the hiring of Mike McCarthy introduced only their fourth new coach in more than a half-century. The three predecessors to McCarthy all won Super Bowls.
The journey from cellar-dwellers to Super Bowl Champions began when Chuck Noll took the reins of the team in 1969. In a career that spanned that year to 1991, Noll led the Steelers to four Super Bowl wins. Bill Cowher was named Steelers head coach in 1992, served in the position for 15 seasons, and added a Vince Lombardi Trophy to their collection.
Mike Tomlin took himself out of the job last January after 19 seasons, and during his tenure the Steelers captured another Super Bowl win and a record that will likely never be broken. In his 19 years with the Steelers, Tomlin never suffered a losing campaign.
Now it is McCarthy’s turn to extend this level of excellence … and he has perhaps a bigger challenge than any of the previous Pittsburgh head coaches except Noll. Noll had to turn a losing franchise into a winner, while McCarthy is entrusted to win while the Pittsburgh talent is not up to the standards handed off to Cowher and Tomlin. The Steelers defense lacks the dominating personnel that has marked this team’s success for generations.
The problem with the Steelers is those consecutive non-losing seasons by Tomlin were impressive in the regular season and earned numerous playoff dates, but Pittsburgh was never the best team in the league after the 2008 season. Good enough to win a majority of their games, but that continued success never allowed Pittsburgh high draft choices to build a dominant team.
The Steelers success under Noll began with a last place team and high draft choices. The success Jimmy Johnson achieved with the Dallas Cowboys began with teams that had as few as one win in a season but the opportunity to pick the cream of the college crop through the draft.
Tomlin won his lone Super Bowl in the 2008 season, and while never dipping down with a losing record to select high in the draft, his coaching was good enough to keep the Steeler contenders but not enough to win it all. Tomlin lost his seven most recent postseason trips with his last win in the playoffs a narrow victory over the Kansas City Chiefs in the 2016 season.
The Steelers were trapped with being good enough but not the best based on their regular season success. It was a similar pattern experienced by the Miami Dolphins while they had Dan Marino as their quarterback. Marino may have been the best quarterback in the league during many of his pro seasons, but he made only one Super Bowl appearance, a loss in his second professional season to Joe Montan and the San Francisco 49ers.
Marino was good enough to win a couple extra games every season for Don Shula and later when Johnson was his head coach, but that success never saw the Dolphins dip in the standings to where they could reload through the NFL draft.
Early returns have Pittsburgh once again winning games while relying on a 42-year-old quarterback that has already announced this is his final season. Aaron Rodgers has shown the grit that has marked his career that will land him in Canton five years after he retires. But picking up extra wins based on his savvy may look good during the regular season, but it is still working against Pittsburgh dropping down enough to reload with the benefit of high draft choices.
While the Steelers might add to their string of consecutive winning seasons, they don’t appear to have a team this year that would break their playoff losing streak. They have won four of their six games while Rodgers has twice led second half comebacks. This week, they meet a Saints team looking to recover from a 2 and 4 season start. The biggest benefit that New Orleans has is that while they are looking to find their groove under second-year quarterback Tyler Shough and his second-year head coach Kellen Moore, nobody in the NFC South Division is running away from them.
This is a division that was won last year with a losing record when the Carolina Panthers advanced to the playoffs with an 8-9 mark. Seems a similar fate is in store this season as the Panthers 3 and 2 won/loss record is good enough to lead the rest of the division by more than a game. The Falcons and Saints come into Week Seven action with two wins each, while the NFC South Division last place Buccaneers have one win and five losses.
So, who needs this game more when they meet across the pond?
The Steelers have a winning record, better than any team in the NFC South Division, but are locked in a three-way tie for first place in the AFC North Division. The Saints, with their dismal won/loss mark, are only one win back in their division.
By my numbers, the Steelers four wins and two losses are slightly ahead of the record their talent warrants. While the Saints, with only two wins, are a notch below what their talent should dictate.
See that?
Both teams need it, but one team has over-achieved and one team has under-achieved.
In the NFL most results are working towards the middle. In this case, the middle dictates a Saints win and a Steelers loss.
Qoxhi Picks: New Orleans Saints (+3½) over Pittsburgh Steelers