Maybe if they hadn’t been so good for so long.
Perhaps if Patrick Mahomes wasn’t still regarded as in his prime.
If their head coach wasn’t so revered.
Yeah, if all those things weren’t true, the Kansas City Chiefs wouldn’t be favored by double-digits this week when they host the New York Jets.
If we just look at this season, the Chiefs, although they ran their season opening win total to five games before losing their last two outings, have a losing record against the point spread. In early season wins, they lost against the Indianapolis Colts and Las Vegas Raiders against the point spread. In those games they were favored by 6 points and 4½ points respectively.
So, if they lost those two games against the number and now have lost two games in a row straight-up, why then are they double-digit favorites this week?
Because of the past.
When their head coach, Andy Reid, was running the Philadelphia Eagles I respected him for his knowledge of X’s and O’s. His game plans were well conceived and his staff and players respected him. But, despite those strengths, I saw him make more mistakes strategically on game day decisions than if Mo, Larry and Curly were deciding situations.
When to punt, when to go for it, when to go for two or settle for a one-point conversion were decisions Reid consistently chose wrong. It is one of the reasons why his talented Eagles teams never won a Super Bowl.
Then later in his career, specifically with the Chiefs, Reid seemed to correct his ways. Then we saw the old Andy rear its ugly head again last week and it likely cost the Chiefs an important win last Sunday in Denver.
Here is the situation. The Chiefs lead by three points with just over two-minutes left in regulation. His team is facing a 4th and 8 from the 36-yard-line. He has a choice here, he could allow Mahomes to work his magic and pick up the first down which would in all probability lock up a Chiefs win. Or, he could punt, and look to pin the Broncos sluggish offense deep and allow his Kansas City defense to lock away the victory.
Or, and this is really a bad choice, he could send kicker Harrison Butker in to attempt a 54-yard field goal in the rain. Butker is having a horrible season and the Chiefs have already signed Justin Tucker to their practice squad with the possibility of making a switch at kicker very soon. Butker used to be good, in fact even from long range early in his career he was a good bet.
But, not now, not in a season he has already missed a league high seven kicks. He has also only made two of six attempts this season from 50 yards or more. He’s got as much of a chance at converting this 54-yard boot as a three-legged mouse has of surviving at a cat convention.
And, lets just imagine for a second, that the thin Mile High air doesn’t lose to the rain and Butker converts this high risk kick. Then the Chiefs lead would go from three to six, still with more than two minutes on the clock allowing the Broncos a win with a touchdown and extra point.
High risk, little to gain, and Reid got what he deserved.
The kick was missed and two plays later the Broncos scored the go-ahead touchdown.
Still, the resilient Mahomes led the Chiefs down to the one-yard-line with 35 seconds on the clock and two timeouts. With the league’s leading rusher in the backfield, Kenneth Walker III, Reid opted for a Mahomes pass which was incomplete. On second down, they did use Walker, but he was stopped for no gain. A penalty by early movement on the offensive line wiped out a would-be winning touchdown pass and Mahomes was then sacked on the next play to end the game in the Broncos favor.
Did Reid make enough mistakes in the final few minutes of that game to reestablish himself as a bonehead on game day strategy?
I think so.
And yet, the Chiefs are double-digit favorites this week. Not because of who they are … but who they were.
Qoxhi Picks: New York Jets (+10) over Kansas City Chiefs